ALERT!

This site is not optimized for Internet Explorer 8 (or older).

Please upgrade to a newer version of Internet Explorer or use an alternate browser such as Chrome or Firefox.

Result Summary for Survey:Thoracic Portal Survey - VATS Lobectomy Training and Instruction

Wednesday, September 21, 2011

By

 

In this survey respondents were asked about their routine approach to assessment and management of patients with non-thymomatous myasthenia gravis (MG).  The majority of respondents surgically manage myasthenia gravis.  Two-thirds of them perform this operation via a full or partial sternotomy.  About 20% of surgeons use VATS approaches, and transcervical and robotic approaches each were used by 5%.

Almost 85% of respondents consider the diagnosis of myasthenia gravis or MG with more than ocular symptoms to be sufficient indications for surgery.  A minority of surgeons, just over 15%, indicated that patients needed to have generalized symptoms before they would consider recommending thymectomy.  The most common surgical goal, favored by two-thirds of respondents, was complete thymectomy, whereas one-third believe that an extended or radical thymectomy is appropriate for management of MG.

Advanced age does not appear to be a contraindication to thymectomy for MG, even though some reports in the literature suggest that outcomes with regards to resolution of MG symptoms are not as favorable in older patients.  Preoperative preparation appears to include 2 or more different techniques for most surgeons.

Almost all surgeons obtain a CT scan as part of the preoperative evaluation.  Only 40% measure lung function, and just over 50% assess acetylcholine receptor antibody status.  MRI is not favored as a method of preoperative evaluation in these patients.  Interestingly, if a small encapsulated nodule consistent with a thymoma is discovered during a minimally invasive thymectomy, two-thirds of respondents would complete the thymectomy using a minimally invasive approach.

This was the first survey in this portal to attract relatively equal numbers of respondents from North America, Europe, and Asia, and there was a larger number than usual of respondents from Africa as well.

1. Do you perform thymectomy for myasthenia gravis?
  answered question 113
 
skipped question
0
  Response
Percent
Response
Count
Yes
98.2% 111
No, that disease is not treated surgically in my center   0.0% 0
No, that disease is treated surgically by other surgeons in my center
1.8% 2
2. What is your standard surgical approach to non-thymomatous myasthenia gravis?
  answered question 113
 
skipped question
0
  Response
Percent
Response
Count
Partial sternotomy
17.7% 20
Full sternotomy
50.4% 57
Transcervical
5.3% 6
Thoracoscopic, bilateral
4.4% 5
Thoracoscopic, unilateral
16.8% 19
Robotic assisted of any type
5.3% 6
3. What is your intent when performing thymectomy for MG?
  answered question 113
 
skipped question
0
  Response
Percent
Response
Count
Complete thymectomy
63.7% 72
Extended or radical thymectomy
36.3% 41
Other   0.0% 0
4. What are your indications for surgery for MG?
  answered question 112
 
skipped question
1
  Response
Percent
Response
Count
Any patient diagnosed with MG is a candidate
49.1% 55
Disease beyond ocular involvement
34.8% 39
Severe generalized disease
16.1% 18
5. Is older age a contraindication to thymectomy for myasthenia gravis?
  answered question 113
 
skipped question
0
  Response
Percent
Response
Count
Definitely
2.7% 3
Maybe
30.1% 34
Probably not
35.4% 40
No
31.9% 36
6. What adjuncts do you or your medical colleagues use to prepare MG patients for surgery (check all that apply)?
  answered question 110
 
skipped question
3
  Response
Percent
Response
Count
Plasmapheresis
65.5% 72
Steroids
70.9% 78
Other pharmacologic immunosuppression
30.9% 34
Intravenous IgG
48.2% 53
7. What evaluations are routine prior to thymectomy for MG (check all that apply)?
  answered question 112
 
skipped question
1
  Response
Percent
Response
Count
CT
97.3% 109
PFTs
39.3% 44
MRI
8.0% 9
Acetylcholine receptor antibody measurement
53.6% 60
8. If a 1.5 cm encapsulated nodule suspicious for thymoma is discovered intraoperatively during a minimally invasive or transcervical thymectomy, how do you manage this?
  answered question 109
 
skipped question
4
  Response
Percent
Response
Count
Convert to an open operation
23.9% 26
Continue with a minimally invasive approach as planned
65.1% 71
Other
11.0% 12
9. In what region do you practice?
  answered question 113
 
skipped question
0
  Response
Percent
Response
Count
North America
31.9% 36
Europe
23.0% 26
Asia
25.7% 29
Africa
5.3% 6
Central or South America
13.3% 15
Australia/New Zealand
0.9% 1

 

Add comment

Log in or register to post comments